The
U.S. military has maintained a constant presence in Haiti since “Operation
Uphold Democracy” helped restore elected President Jean-Bertrand Aristide
to power in 1994. While U.S. combat and peacekeeping contingents have
long since left Haiti, a U.S. “Support Group”
based in Port-au-Prince has maintained the U.S. presence. This presence
is scheduled to end in early 2000, as both the U.S. Southern Command
(Southcom), which coordinates all U.S. military
activities in the hemisphere, and Congress have called for its termination.
Once the Support Group leaves, the U.S. military will maintain a less
permanent presence in Haiti through periodic Humanitarian Civic Assistance
(HCA) deployments.
In
March 1999 the commander-in-chief of Southcom, Gen. Charles Wilhelm,
recommended that the Support Group be withdrawn for security reasons.
" ">[A]t
this point, I am more concerned about force protection than cash outlays.
The unrest generated by political instability requires us to constantly
reassess the safety and security environment in which our troops are
living and working. I have recommended that we terminate our permanent
military presence in Haiti, and conduct routine periodic engagement
activities.1
Congressional
Republicans joined the call to bring troops out of Haiti, inserting
Section 1232 into the 2000 National Defense Authorization Act (P.L.
106-65). Section 1232 prohibits the Department of Defense from funding
any continuous presence of U.S. forces in Haiti as part of "Operation
Uphold Democracy" after May 31, 2000. While it allows temporary
deployments to take place after May 31, the new law requires the President
to report them to Congress within 96 hours of their inception. The report
must specify the purpose and expected end date of each deployment.
The
Support Group handled logistics for a steady series of military Humanitarian
Civic Assistance (HCA) activities. Chiefly construction
projects and medical services, these activities occurred within the
framework of Southcom’s region-wide “New Horizons”
series of HCA exercises.
Between
the Support Group and the HCA projects, an average of 496 U.S. military
personnel were present in Haiti on an average day in 1998. The Southern
Command estimates that the U.S. presence in Haiti cost the Defense Department
$20,085,000 in 1998. The funding has been drawn from the military services’
operations and maintenance accounts.2
After
Haiti’s military disintegrated upon Aristide’s return, assistance from
the United States and other donor countries helped establish a police
force to keep order. Particularly out of concern for drug transshipments
through Haitian territory, the United States remains heavily engaged
in efforts to strengthen and develop the recently created force. In
its 2000 Foreign Operations Appropriations bill, Congress urged the
administration to place a high priority on “aggressive action to support
the Haitian National Police (HNP), including support for efforts by
the Inspector General to purge corrupt and politicized elements.”
According
to the State Department’s 2000 Congressional Presentation for Foreign
Operations, the main targets of police aid are the Haitian Coast
Guard (HCG) and a “fully vetted and polygraphed” Counternarcotics Unit
(CNU). Smaller amounts of assistance go to a border patrol unit and
a Joint Intelligence Coordination Center.3
Most
U.S. police assistance for Haiti is funded through the State Department’s
International Narcotics Control (INC) program,
the Caribbean Regional Fund of the Foreign Military
Financing (FMF) program, and the International
Military Education and Training (IMET) program.
Recent
support for the 96-member, eight-boat Haitian Coast Guard (HCG) includes
equipment (particularly three 40-foot patrol boats), infrastructure
improvements, and training.4
In 1998, the State Department’s February 1999 International Narcotics
Control Strategy Report (INCSR) estimated, the HCG received infrastructure
development services worth $350,000 and training worth $300,000.5
Among the U.S.-funded infrastructure improvements are base renovation
and construction at Les Cayes, Cap Haitien, and Jacmel, and the construction
of a police inspection point on the Dominican border at Malpasse.6
Since
April 1996 the U.S. and Canadian Coast Guards have conducted a full
time training and advisory program for the HCG. Under the terms of a
1997 maritime counternarcotics agreement – which Haiti’s deadlocked
Parliament never formally ratified – U.S. Coast Guard
craft with Haitian officials aboard as “shipriders” carry out narcotics
seizures in Haitian territorial waters.7
Shipriders are also used in “Frontier Lance,” a periodic Coast Guard
anti-drug operation involving both Haiti and the Dominican Republic.
The
Justice Department’s Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA),
which increased its staffing in Haiti from two to seven in 1998, has
been involved in many of the Haitian National Police’s anti-drug initiatives,
from the creation of units to the installation of computer networks.
DEA also coordinated Operation Genesis, a drug interdiction initiative
involving Haitian and Dominican forces along the two countries’ common
border. According to the INCSR, the operation “resulted
in unprecedented exchanges of law enforcement cooperation between the
two countries.”8
The
2000 Congressional Presentation notes that the Justice Department’s
International Criminal Investigations Training Assistance Program (ICITAP)
“completed training of 6,500 recruits to the newly-formed HNP. Training
continues as the force continues to grow and improve its capabilities.”9
Coast Guard students made up the majority of trainees funded by the
IMET program.
Haiti
is not a significant customer for U.S. arms, though small amounts of small
weapons, ammunition, and communications equipment have been purchased
recently through the Foreign Military Sales (FMS)
and Direct Commercial Sales (DCS) programs.
Sources:
Sources
for "country snapshot":
United
States, Department of State, Background Notes: Haiti, (Washington:
Department of State: March 1998) <http://www.state.gov/www/background_notes/haiti_0398_bgn.html>.
United
States, Central Intelligence Agency, The World Factbook 1999,
(Washington: Central Intelligence Agency: 1999) <"
" lang="ES-CR">http://www.odci.gov/cia/publications/factbook/ha.html>.
1
United States, U.S. Southern Command, “Posture Statement Of General
Charles E. Wilhelm, United States Marine Corps Commander In Chief, United
States Southern Command Before The Senate Armed Services Committee,”
March 4, 1999.
2
U.S. Southern Command, March 4, 1999.
3"MS
Mincho"; ">U.S. Department of State, Bureau of International Narcotics
and Law Enforcement Affairs, International Narcotics Control Strategy
Report, 1998, (Washington: Department of State: February 1999):
<http://www.state.gov/www/global/narcotics_law/1998_narc_report/major/Haiti.html>.
United
States, Department of State, Congressional Presentation for Foreign
Operations, Fiscal Year 2000, (Washington: Department of State:
March 1999): 896-7.
4"MS
Mincho"; ">Bureau of International Narcotics and Law Enforcement
Affairs, International Narcotics Control Strategy Report, 1998.
Department
of State, Congressional Presentation for Foreign Operations, Fiscal
Year 2000 896.
5"MS
Mincho"; ">Bureau of International Narcotics and Law Enforcement
Affairs, International Narcotics Control Strategy Report, 1998.
"MS
Mincho"; ">6
Bureau of International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs, International
Narcotics Control Strategy Report, 1998.
"MS
Mincho"; ">7
Bureau of International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs, International
Narcotics Control Strategy Report, 1998.
"MS
Mincho"; ">8
Bureau of International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs, International
Narcotics Control Strategy Report, 1998.
"MS
Mincho"; ">9Department
of State, Congressional Presentation for Foreign Operations, Fiscal
Year 2000 897.