As printed in
The Institute for America's Future
February 02, 2007
Castro's
Legacy
Wayne S. Smith
Raúl
Castro has been acting president of Cuba since July 31, 2006. His
brother, Fidel, passed the office to him then because of a serious
illness. At this point, it is not clear whether Fidel Castro will
recover and resume the presidency. It seems unlikely. But regardless
of whether he does or not, he is now 80 and in poor health. One
way or the other, his almost half-century rule in Cuba is nearing
an end. What will be his legacy? Has the Cuba he leaves behind registered
gains over Cuba as it was when he took power in 1959? Will it have
a brighter future? And is it supported by the Cuban people?
The
answers to those questions are mixed. Castro first and foremost
is and always has been a committed egalitarian. He despises any
system in which one class or group of people lives much better than
another. He wanted a system that provided the basic needs to all—enough
to eat, health care, adequate housing and education. The authoritarian
nature of the Cuban Revolution stems largely from his commitment
to that goal. Castro was convinced that he was right, and that his
system was for the good of the people. Thus, anyone who stood against
the revolution stood also against the Cuban people and that, in
Castro’s eyes, was simply unacceptable. There is, then, very
little in the way of individual freedoms –especially freedom
of expression and assembly. And there are political prisoners—those
who have expressed positions against the revolution—though
today only some 300, down markedly from the number at the outset
of the revolution.
And
did the system provide that promised better way of life? It can
be said that during the years of the Cuban-Soviet alliance, when
Cuba enjoyed most favorable terms of trade with the Soviet Union,
resulting in what amounted to a subsidy of five to six billion dollars
a year, the Cuban people were indeed well off. They had free (and
excellent) health care, education up through the post-graduate level,
adequate housing, enough to eat, and various other benefits. Then
came the collapse of the Soviet Union and the end of Cuba’s
subsidy. Cuba went through some very difficult years—years
of serious shortages of almost everything—of 18-hour-a-day
blackouts and other difficulties.
It
is a tribute to the durability of the Cuban people, and to a number
of reforms to the economy carried out by the government, that they
survived. But survive they did, and survive also did the revolution.
At this point, the Cuban economy is making a strong comeback, thanks
in part to new economic relationships with Venezuela and China,
to a possible new oil field off the north coast, with other nations
already bidding for drilling rights, to the fact that the price
of nickel, Cuba’s largest export, is at an all-time high and
that tourism continues to flourish and bring in much-needed hard
currency despite U.S. travel controls blocking American tourists.
The economy grew by at least eight percent in 2005 and closer to
12 percent in 2006.
For
the average Cuban, life is still difficult. There are still shortages
of almost all the basic necessities. Few go hungry, but the diet
tends to be monotonous. Even so, the blackouts are now a thing of
the past and there is renewed hope for the future. And they still
have their free health care and education—something they do
not want to give up!
Expectations
in Miami and Washington had been that once Fidel Castro disappeared
from the scene, the Revolution would crumble. But that, of course,
has not been the case. Six months after Fidel passed the baton to
Raúl, there has been no sign whatever of unrest. The Cuban
people have accepted the transition with calm maturity—indicating
a higher level of support for the Revolution than the exiles in
Miami or the Bush administration had thought possible. Indeed, a
recent Gallup poll conducted in Cuba indicated that 49 percent of
the Cuban people supported Fidel Castro. Cuban officials strongly
contest that finding, insisting that the percentage of supporters
is much, much higher. But even as it stands, the poll indicates
that a higher percentage of Cubans support Fidel than the percentage
of Americans who support President Bush!
And
what about Cuba’s place, its prestige, on the world stage?
Here the gains are unquestionable. Before 1959, Cuba was considered
as something of a banana republic. It played virtually no role in
the international arena. But under Castro, it has played a prominent
role, indeed at times a role that often resembled that of a world
power.
It
played a crucial part, for example, in bringing about revolutionary
change in South Africa—and, indeed, throughout Africa. At
the all-out battle of Cuito Cuanavale in Angola in 1987, Cuban forces
defeated South Africa. The Cubans showed that the “white giants”
could be beaten. All else followed from that. The South Africans
decided to negotiate. Angola and Namibia became independent and
vast internal changes began in South Africa itself. By 1994, Nelson
Mandela was president. As Mandela put it in a speech on September
4, 1998, change was made possible “… because of Cuba’s
selfless support for the struggle to free all of South Africa’s
people and the countries of our region from the inhumane and destructive
system of apartheid. For that we thank the Cuban people from the
bottom of our heart.”
Cuba
no longer exerts influence abroad by military means. The world situation
has changed. But its influence is still felt around the world, nonetheless,
now increasingly through a vast plan of medical assistance it began
in 1998. Cuba now has some 25,000 medical personnel abroad, providing
assistance in over 68 countries, with 14,000 in Venezuela alone.
Indeed, it has more medical personnel deployed around the world
than has the World Health Organization, and is training doctors
and nurses for a broad range of countries at the huge Latin American
Medical School in Havana. It has received kudos from a diverse range
of leaders such as President Pervez Musharraf of Pakistan and Hugo
Chavez of Venezuela.
And,
finally, Cuba’s standing in Latin America has perhaps never
been higher. Wherever Castro has gone in the hemisphere over the
past few years, he has been received with warm applause. Why? Because
he stood up to the United States, has defied Washington and gone
his own way. That is something virtually all Latin Americans respect
and admire.
|