As printed in the
The South Florida
Sun-Sentinel
Tuesday, May 22, 2007
U.S. BENDING BACKWARDS NOT TO
EXTRADITE
By
Wayne S. Smith
Facing
a barrage of criticism over its handling of the case of the notorious
terrorist Luis Posada Carriles, the Bush administration has had
nothing to say, no explanation whatever for the fact that it can
only be seen as sheltering him. And no one is more silent than Attorney
General Alberto Gonzalez, even though U.S. Rep. William Delahunt,
D-Mass., pointed out to him in a hearing on May 10 that "the
buck stops with you."Gonzalez is, after all, our senior law
enforcement official. All he could say, however, was that he'd have
to "go back and look at this case so I can give you an answer."
His
usual evasiveness. Go back and look at it? The case has been pending
for two years and the consequences of our inaction, as indicated
below, are clear.
Posada
has a long record of terrorist acts. Just out of prison in Panama
(where he'd been serving a sentence for "endangering public
safety"), in March of 2005, he showed up in Miami. Everyone
knew he was there, but U.S. authorities made no effort to apprehend
him until May, when he gave a press conference and forced their
hand.
He
was then arrested, but rather than charging him with acts of terrorism,
he was simply charged with illegal entry and sent off to El Paso
for an administrative immigration hearing, a complete farce. He
was ordered deported, but, as U.S. authorities already knew, there
were no countries willing to take him except Venezuela, which had
already requested his extradition for the 1976 bombing of the Cubana
airliner. The federal judge, however, on nothing more than the opinion
of a long-time associate of Posada's, ruled that he could not be
extradited to Venezuela for fear that he would be tortured there.
To
hold him longer, the government then came up with a charge of giving
false statements on his application for entry. Another sham, which
finally ended on May 8, when Judge Kathleen Cardone, seeing clearly
that the whole thing was nothing more than an effort to finesse
the case, charged the government with bad faith and "engaging
in fraud, deceit and trickery." That being the case, she said,
"this court is left with no choice but to dismiss the indictment."
So
what will the government do now? On May 10, the attorney general
seemed to have not a clue. And yet, the issue is perfectly clear.
Venezuela has asked for his extradition. We have an extradition
treaty with Venezuela. Under that treaty and others, we must either
extradite him to Venezuela or we must indict him for acts of terrorism
and try him in the United States. Otherwise, we will be in blatant
violation of international treaties, and will be guilty of openly
sheltering a terrorist.
President
Bush has often taken the position that "if you harbor a terrorist,
you're equally as guilty as the terrorist." Where, then, would
our harboring of Posada leave George W. Bush?
Why
is the administration so reluctant to take appropriate action against
Posada? Doubtless because dating back to the early 1960s, he was
a long-time agent of the CIA. Were some of his terrorist acts carried
out at the behest of the CIA? In any event, he knows far too much.
And his lawyer has stated clearly that if the government moves to
prosecute him, he'll tell all.
There
will be hearings in Congress on the Posada case in the next few
days. It will be fascinating to see what position the government
takes, and if Gonzalez has anything more than his usual evasions
to offer, especially with a vote of no-confidence against him looming
in the Senate.
Wayne
S. Smith is a senior fellow at the Center for International Relations
in Washington, D.C. and an adjunct professor of Latin American studies
at the Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore.
|